Marisa Tashman Coppel, a seasoned lawyer helming the legal team at the Blockchain Association, recently offered her take on the latest twist in the SEC’s high-stakes case against Coinbase. Through a series of tweets, Coppel broke down the recent court order, highlighting wins and challenges on the road ahead.
One major victory, in Coppel’s eyes, was the court dismissing the SEC’s allegation that Coinbase Wallet operates as an unregistered broker. She branded this claim a “drastic overreach” by the regulators and a “huge win for DeFi” that will benefit peer-to-peer tech and developers.
However, the court allowed the SEC’s other claims to proceed, which Coppel views as a mixed bag. Not ideal, she admitted, but it does allow Coinbase to undertake the discovery process and dig up facts that could bolster their defense down the line when arguing for summary judgment.
Preliminary Stage Dynamics for Coinbase Case
Coppel reminded followers that at this preliminary stage, courts must accept the SEC’s alleged facts at face value, stymieing deeper analysis for now. But as discovery unfolds, she anticipates more scrutiny on issues like token decentralization, the role of token holders themselves, and how utility factors into the investment contract analysis.
One part of the ruling drew particular ire from the blockchain advocate. She took issue with the court’s expansive definition of “ecosystem” and its argument that tokens are investment contracts because buyers essentially invest in these token ecosystems and their fluctuating values. Coppel contended this logic gets carried away, potentially roping in collectibles like Barbie dolls, Pokemon cards, and even luxury watches as unregistered securities.
To illustrate her point, she raised the example of Lakers season tickets. Fans buy into the team’s ecosystem and rely on its performance maintaining ticket values and demand. But, she argued, surely no one would claim the tickets themselves are investment contracts.
While acknowledging that courts rarely grant full dismissal of claims against government agencies this early, Coppel remains optimistic about Coinbase’s chances as the case ramps up. She praised the elite legal squad led by Paul Grewal as “some of the best lawyers in the world” and described their arguments as robust.
Although the SEC will likely attempt to use this ruling to support its positions in other crypto cases, like the recent Binance suit, Coppel hopes courts will be reluctant to place too much weight on an opinion rendered prior to any factual discovery.
Related Reading | Did Cardano’s Founder Code Its Genesis? Hoskinson Breaks Silence